Scholarship in Chaos! Flying High on the Web? Or in Free Fall?
The Tuesday evening session was not very well attended this year. I found little I will be able to use there, but I wanted to share a few goodies.
Representatives from Google Scholar, Microsoft's Windows Live Academic, and Elsevier's Scirus comprised the panel. The moderator was Rich Wiggins from Michigan State University, who started by projecting this scary thought.

Librarians in the audience pointed out that Google and Microsoft do not include scholarly blogs in their data collection, which they said are proliferating as researchers weary of the time involved in getting published in a juried publication.
The lack of a controlled vocabulary for scholarly web searching also was bemoaned. One law librarian who works at the Library of Congress said it prevents librarians and researchers from being penalized by what they don't know. She provided the example of different cultural terms for the concept of divorce. The panelists also were exhorted to offer an accurate date search.
Rich Wiggins asked each panelist, "What have you observed about the users of your products?"
The Scirus rep's reply: "People start broad and then refine. People want to have the tools to refine. People have two or three favorite search engines, not just one."
The Microsoft rep's reply: "The breadth of use is broader in the use of scholarly works than we anticipated."
The Google rep's reply: "The only unusual thing about scholarly searchers is that they aren’t very different from normal searchers at all. They only use significant use of advanced search to limit the date to last five years." (And that's one advanced search feature that rarely works accurately!)
Representatives from Google Scholar, Microsoft's Windows Live Academic, and Elsevier's Scirus comprised the panel. The moderator was Rich Wiggins from Michigan State University, who started by projecting this scary thought.

Librarians in the audience pointed out that Google and Microsoft do not include scholarly blogs in their data collection, which they said are proliferating as researchers weary of the time involved in getting published in a juried publication.
The lack of a controlled vocabulary for scholarly web searching also was bemoaned. One law librarian who works at the Library of Congress said it prevents librarians and researchers from being penalized by what they don't know. She provided the example of different cultural terms for the concept of divorce. The panelists also were exhorted to offer an accurate date search.
Rich Wiggins asked each panelist, "What have you observed about the users of your products?"
The Scirus rep's reply: "People start broad and then refine. People want to have the tools to refine. People have two or three favorite search engines, not just one."
The Microsoft rep's reply: "The breadth of use is broader in the use of scholarly works than we anticipated."
The Google rep's reply: "The only unusual thing about scholarly searchers is that they aren’t very different from normal searchers at all. They only use significant use of advanced search to limit the date to last five years." (And that's one advanced search feature that rarely works accurately!)
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home